I recall with great clarity the time when Marshall Crenshaw and his bandmates appeared at my college during the spring semester of my senior year. Not sure the rest of the crowd there that day would remember, though.
Every year my school hosted something called Dandelion Day, a day filled with BBQ, outdoor fun and games, music, and mushrooms. The hallucinogenic variety, not the sauteed kind. It was a time-honored tradition that a conglomerate of students would score sacks of mushrooms that were doled out in a kind of Eastern bloc distribution method to the grey sky'd, still-chilly campus. I didn't indulge, but I enjoyed observing with my girlfriend at the time (the rebound girl after the big college girlfriend break-up) the whole scene of uptight pre-med and engineering students tripping out in silly splendor one last time before embarking on their uptight silly careers.
"People, Marshall is not going to play any more," the Brit-sounding concert impresario shouted into the mike, "Until that bloke gets down off of that scaffolding!" The crowd roared and continued to encourage the tripped out dude who had climbed up on top of the stage overhang. I'm not sure it mattered to me, or to anybody else whether Marshall continued. He'd already played the songs I knew at the time, Someday, Someway primarily, and it was honestly more fun to watch the whole disaster waiting to happen scene with the promoter screaming, the roadies climbing up to get that guy who wouldn't come down, and the whole crowd in a delirious mess. It was 1985, it was a mere five years since his first album came out, and it already seemed like Marshall was winding down and was on the oldies tour.
It was later that year when I was on my own, away from home, starting to find myself after college, that I finally picked up that first Marshall Crenshaw album and then soon his album of the time Downtown, and I was gone. I was broken up with those college girls, still bitter, still moping, and every song coming out of my speaker box was a simple rock song about...well...about me:
I'll be stronger when she's off my mind
I hope she finds what she's been tryin' to find
And as life goes on and time goes by
Will her heart ever be satisfied
There she goes again with another guy.
I'd play them over and over and over. In my room, in my car. Every song about losing a love, heartbreak, going out there alone. (Is there a single song in his catalog that involves actually being happy with a current love? They are all about yearning for a lost love or an unattained love. Maybe Whenever You're On My Mind. But that girl might be imaginary, too!) Little Wild One, Blues Is King, Distance Between Me and You. He played on every song of the soundtrack of that year, that lonely year between the time I left college and then found Rebecca. My cynical girl.
Well I'll know right away by the look in her eye
She harbors no illusions and she's worldly-wise
And I'll know when I give her a listen that she
She's what I've been missin'
What I've been missin'.
We've been listening to a lot of Marshall Crenshaw lately with our boys. He's an uncomplicated, smart, rocking American Elvis. (Costello variety). They really dig his late '80s song Calling Out For Love At Crying Time, his hooks, his ringing guitar, his sweet, melodic voice. Simple, straight-forward rock music. It's actually tough to do, and nobody seems to do it anymore. Marshall Crenshaw didn't follow any new fad or craze. Didn't get pinned to any musical style like rockabilly or cow punk or new wave or next wave. He wrote and performed rock songs, the 2-3 minute pop song (stretched it out to 4 as time went by, but then so did the Beatles). Commercially flawed but musically true. Oh, and he's still doing it.
Okay. If all that's true. Then why did we decide as a group that we'll see The Who concert on the same night that Marshall Crenshaw is playing at Jammin' Java?
Really, really tough choice. Impossible choice. For us. It came down to these factors:
1. We'll get a chance to see Marshall Crenshaw again. He'll come back, he always does, with the big cult following he enjoys in the DC area. Who knows...maybe even this year?
2. We might not get that same chance with The 2 Who. (Though I recall a Rolling Stone concert tour that brought them to Rich Stadium in Buffalo and people were saying this could be it, the last time they'd tour, better see them now. That was 1981 in support of Tattoo You.) It's getting fairly late for The Who, though, don't you think?
3. I don't get plenty of agreement on this one in my family, but I considered that Endless Wire has some very good songs that I'd love to see them perform, including Mike Post Theme, despite its wacky TV show title. It's one for The Who pantheon. Best since You Better You Bet (I know that's not saying much.)
4. The Who songs obviously mean more to us. There's no question. To prove that point, the boys and I gave ourselves one minute on the clock to list as many Who songs as we'd like to hear them perform. We gave a minute to Marshall Crenshaw, too. No contest. We could rattle off more than twice as many Who songs we'd love to hear. We ran out of time with The Who. We exhausted our Marshall Crenshaw list in half a minute. That settled it. I went to Ticketmaster and paid the relatively enormous freight.
It'll be fun. I have little doubt. It's not on their tour setlist but we'll be shouting out for Substitute. Perhaps too much to ask for them to play A Quick One. I agree with Bob that's it's not really The Who without Moon and the Ox. Nothing we can do about that. Pete's okay with me. He writes adult-sized rock songs, like Costello and Ray Davies do, too. Given the chance to see somebody so vital to the background music of our lives, I figure we have to do it, and join the crowd.
But there will always be a little bit of doubt in there. Maybe. Maybe we should've opted to get in a little closer, a little tighter, with a drink in my hand and my arm around Rebecca. And make up for that time when I paid less attention to the music and more attention to the guy up on the scaffolding. Someday, someway. Won't get fooled again?